skip to main content skip to footer

Ice Cream

Enjoy Your Favorites, We Make Them to Order!

Shakes • Malts • Sundaes... limited only by your imagination!

Fay's Evelyn Bay is the Charlotte Shop that sells shakes and the Charlotte, MI shop that sells sundaes - made to order! Stop in for fresh Hershey's Ice Cream - year round!

We have an assortment of flavors!


Assorted flavors of ice cream on cones placed in a cone holder